A story from the old Soviet Union, written by the Russian writer Vladimir Dudintsev, still teaching us things today. And here is a written version from a 2013 post.
Some 50 years ago, I received as a Christmas present a book titled
"Russian Science Fiction." All the stories in that book made a deep
impression on me, but there was one that has remained in my mind more
than the others; a curious story titled "A New Year's Tale".
I was, maybe, 12 at that time and, of course, I couldn't understand
everything of that story and I didn't pay attention to the name of the
author. But, as time went by, I didn't forget it; rather, it became
entrenched in my mind, progressively acquiring more meaning and more
importance. I reread it not long ago, and it came back to my mind during
a recent trip to Russia. So, let me tell you this story as I remember
it.
"A New Year's Tale" tells of one year of life of the protagonist,
a researcher in a scientific laboratory somewhere in the Soviet Union.
Dudintsev manages to tell the story without ever giving specific details
about anything: no place names, no names of the characters, not even of
the protagonist. It is a feat of literary virtuosity; it gives the
story an atmosphere of a fairy tale but, at the same time, it is very,
very specific.
It took me time before I could understand the hints that Dudintsev gives
all over the text, but after many trips to Russia, everything fell in
place. It is curious how Dudintsev managed to catch so well the
atmosphere of a research lab in the Soviet Union; he was not a
scientific researcher. But that's what makes a great storyteller, after
all: understanding what one is describing - and feeling something for
it.
The story starts with a debate - rather, a quarrel - that the
protagonist has with someone termed "a provincial academic" (we are not
told his name). This provincial academic should be nothing more than a
nuisance, but the protagonist can't avoid engaging in the debate. He
understands that he is losing time, that he should be doing something
more useful, more important. But he just can't sit down and do his job.
While the protagonist is entangled in this useless quarrel, the chief of
the laboratory (again, we are not told his name) dabbles in archeology
and one day he tells his coworkers of some work of his somewhere in the
Caucasus, where they found an ancient tomb. There was an owl engraved on
the tombstone and an inscription that they could decipher. It says "...and the years of his life were 900...."
Now, what could that mean? Could the man buried there have lived 900
years? No, of course not. But then, what does the inscription mean?
Well, someone says, that must mean that this man spent his life so well and so fully that it was like his years had been 900.
The discussion goes on. What does it mean to live such a full life? The
researchers try to find an answer but, at some moment, they hear the
voice of someone who usually keeps silent at these reunions. We are told
that he is from far away, not Russian, that is. We can imagine that
this man doesn't have a Russian name, but we are not told names. So, he
is an outsider and he comes with a completely different viewpoint; he is
"the foreign scientist" even though in the old Soviet Union,
theoretically, there was no such distinction. "You see, comrades," he
says, "it is very simple. To live a full life, you must always choose
the greatest satisfactions, the highest joys you can find."
At this point, we hear the voice of the political commissioner of the
lab. Apparently, there was usually someone in the scientific academies
in the Soviet Union who was in charge of making sure that Soviet
Scientists would not fall into doing decadent capitalist science. So, he
stands up and he tells the foreign scientist, "Well, comrade, don't you
think one should also work for the people or something like that?" And
the foreign scientist answers, "You are so backward, comrade. Don't you
understand? The greatest satisfaction, the highest joy one can have in
life is exactly that: working for the people!"
After that the discussion is over, the protagonist of the story reflects
on the words of the foreign scientist and he resolves to start doing
something serious in his life. He decides to start doing experiments,
advance his theory. We are not told exactly what he is doing, but we
understand that he is working on something important; research that has
to do with capturing and storing solar light. And he manages to work on
that for some time. Then, his colleagues bring to him another paper
written by his provincial antagonist. So, he feels he has to answer
that, and then the provincial academician writes a response.... and the
protagonist finds himself entangled again into this argument.
Things are back to the silly normalcy of before, but then something
happens. The protagonist finds that he is being stalked. Someone, or
something, is following him all the time. When he sees it in full he
discovers that it is an owl. A giant owl, almost as big as a man,
looking at him. He thinks it is a hallucination, which of course it must
be. But he keeps seeing this owl over and over.
So, the protagonist goes to see a doctor and he tells him of the owl.
The doctor pales. After a thorough physical examination, the doctor
tells him: "you have one year to live, more or less." We are not told of
what specific sickness the protagonist suffers. He asks, "but why the
owl?" And the doctor answers, "we are studying that. You are not the
only one. The owl is a symptom." Then, the doctor looks at the
protagonist straight in his eyes and he says, "I can tell you something.
Those who see the owl, have a chance to be saved."
In the meantime, there had been a long discussion between the
protagonist and the foreign scientist, the one who had so well silenced
the political commissioner. So, the foreign scientist had told to the
protagonist his story, obliquely, yes, but clearly understandable. His
fellow countrymen had not liked the idea that he had left the country to
become a scientist. They are described as gangsters and criminals, but
we have a feeling that there was something more at stake than just petty
crimes. This man had made a choice and that had meant to make a clean
break from his country and his culture; it had meant to accept the new
Soviet Communist society. Now, he was spending his time in this new
world trying to get his "greatest satisfactions and highest joys" by
working for the people. And, because of that, his former countrymen had
condemned him to death. So, he had changed his name and his identity,
and he had even surgically changed his face to become unrecognizable.
But he knew that "they" were looking for him and they would find him at
some moment.
So, the destiny of the protagonist and of the foreign scientist are
somehow parallel, they both have a limited time. After having seen the
doctor, the protagonist understands the situation and he rushes to
search for the foreign scientist. They can work together, they can join
forces, in this way, maybe they can.... but in horror, he discovers
that the foreign scientist has been killed.
In panic, the protagonist desperately looks for the notes he had
collected over the years. But the cleaning lady tells him that she had
used them to start the fire in the stove. She had no idea that they
could have been important. The protagonist feels like he is walking in a
nightmare. Just one year and he has lost his notes. He starts from
scratch.... his great discovery.... how can he do? Yet, he decides to
try.
He becomes absorbed in his work. He works harder and harder. Staying in
the lab night and day and, when he goes home, he keeps working. His
colleagues note the change; they are surprised that he doesn't react
anymore to the attacks of the provincial academician, but he doesn't
care (which is, by the way, a good lesson on how to handle our modern
Internet flames). He still sees the owl; always bigger and coming closer
to him, the owl has become something of a familiar creature, almost a
friend.
Then, someone appears. It is a woman, described as having "well-formed
shoulders" (of course, we are not told her name!). The protagonist
recognizes her. It is not the first time he has seen her. He remembers
having seen her with the now dead foreign Scientist.
The protagonist has no time for a love story. He has to work. He tries
to ignore the woman but he is also attracted to her. He can concede her
just a few words. Ten minutes, maybe. So they talk and the woman tells
him. "It is you, I recognize you! You can't fool me!" The protagonist
remembers something that the foreign scientist had told him; that he had
his face surgically changed to escape from his enemies. Now, this woman
thinks that the protagonist is really her former lover, who changed
again face and appearance and didn't tell that not even to her.
The protagonist tries to deny that he is the former lover of the woman
but, curiously, he doesn't succeed, not even to himself. In a way, he becomes
the other, acting like him in his complete immersion in his work. The
protagonist discovers that the foreign scientist had assembled a
complete laboratory at home, much better than the lab at the academy. So
he moves there, with the woman with the well-formed shoulders (and the
owl comes, too, perching on a branch just outside the window). Then, the
protagonist even discovers that the foreign scientist was secretly
copying his notes and he gave them to the woman, who has kept them for
him. With these notes, he can gain months of work. Maybe he can make it
in one year, maybe.....
The last part of the story goes on at a feverish pace. The protagonist
becomes sicker and sicker; to the point that he has to stay in bed and
it is the woman with the well-formed shoulders who takes up the work in
the lab. And the owl perches on the bed head. But they manage to get
some important results and that's enough to catch the attention of the
lab boss. He orders everyone in the lab to come there and help the
protagonist (and the woman with the well-formed shoulders) to move on
with the experiments.
In the final scene, the year has ended and we see the protagonist in
bed, dying. But his colleagues show him the results of the experiment:
something so bright, so beautiful, unbelievably bright and beautiful. We
are not told exactly what it is, anyway it is a way to catch sunlight
in a compact form: a new form of energy, a new understanding of the
working of the sun - we don't know, but it is something fantastic. Even
the owl looks at that thing, curious. The protagonist hears the sound of
bells from the window. A new year is starting. We are not told whether
he lives or not, but in any case, it is a new beginning and, whatever it
happens, they'll tell of him that the years of his life had been 900.
And here we are. You see, it is a magic story. It keeps your attention;
you want to know if the protagonist lives or not and you want to know if
he manages to make his great discovery. But it is also the story of the
life and of the mind of scientists that I think is not easy to find in
novels or short stories. It is curious that Dudintsev did so well
because, as I said, he wasn't a scientist, he was a novelist. But he
managed to catch so incredibly well the life of a scientist - of a
scientist working in the Soviet Union, yes, but not just that.
Dudintsev's portrait of science and scientists goes beyond the quirks of
the old Soviet world.
Yes, in Soviet science there were things that look strange for us, such
as having a political commissioner in the lab to watch what scientists
are doing. But that's just a minor feature and today in the West we have
plenty of different -- and heavier -- constraints on what we do that
don't involve a dumb political commissioner. The point is that
scientists often work as if their life were to last just one year; at
least during the productive time of their life; when they are trying to
compress each year as if it were to be 900 years long. It is their lot:
the search for the discovery, being so deeply absorbed in their work,
being remote from everyone else; obsessed with owls that they alone can
see.
And yet, Dudintsev's story is so universal that it goes beyond the
peculiar mind of scientists. It is the story of all men, all over the
world, of what we do and how we spend our life. And the key of the story
is the woman with the well-formed shoulders. She recognizes her former
lover in the protagonist, or she feigns to recognize him. It is him or
it is not him - we are not told, but it doesn't matter. What matter is
her devotion to her man. It is so touching: you perceive true love in
this attitude. In the end, that's the key to the whole story: whatever
we do in life, we do it for those we love.
Some of us are scientists, some aren't. But it is not a piece of bad
advice to live your life as if you wanted each year to be 900 years
long. And every new year is a new beginning.